Nothing beats the experience of preparing evenly-cooked tasty meals. Pans are common utensils in any kitchen, while the broiler pan is rarely seen in most kitchens.

If you’re seeking to prepare evenly-cooked food, broiler pans are the best option. It’s designed to direct heat to the food above rather than below, as in the traditional pan.

These pans come in different sizes, shapes, materials, and brands. It might get confusing trying to find the right broiler pan for you. Keep reading this article to know what to look for when shopping for one and a list of the ten best broiler pans.

What is a Broiler Pan?

Before you learn what a broiler pan is, it’s essential to know what broiling is to understand how it operates.

Broiling is a cooking method where food is placed directly on top of the heat, reaching 500 degrees Fahrenheit. These temperatures enable the food to cook quickly and evenly.

Due to the temperatures, regular pans will start melting and can pose a significant danger in the kitchen. However, a broiler pan can withstand heat due to its heavy-duty construction.

Top 10 Broiler Pans Available On The Market (Reviews)

The following is a list of the best broiler pans and their features that will help you do your search for one easier:

1. Range Kleen BP106X two-piece Porcelain Steel Broiler pan

Range Kleen BP106X two-piece Porcelain Steel Broiler pan

The range Kleen broiler pan is a heavy-duty, two-piece pan made of steel and porcelain.

Its construction enables it to withstand temperatures of up to 1025 degrees Fahrenheit. You may use the pan for broiling and baking both meat and vegetables.

It has a grill that removes excess fat drippings when broiling meat and has an OEM certification. The pan materials are easy to clean and are dishwasher safe.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
The pan’s materials are made from reinforced porcelain steelIts size limits it to preparing small meals
The pan can broil and bake
It can cook different types of food
It can be used indoors and outdoors
The pan has an excellent anti-stick coating and finish

2. Granite Ware 3-Piece Set, Bake, Broiler Pan & Grill

Granite Ware 3-Piece Set, Bake, Broiler Pan & Grill

Measuring 15.75 by 9.88 by 2 inches, the Granite Ware broiler pan is one of the best pans for broiling meat.

The pan is a three-piece set made from alloy steel with a porcelain enamel finish that makes it nonstick. You can use the pan for broiling, grilling, and baking.

It does not have any PFOA and PTFE that are considered harmful chemicals.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
Its PFOA and PTFE freeThe pan is prone to chipping and then regularly dropped
It’s an excellent pan for broiling meatYou cannot use the pan on a glass cooktop
Its dishwasher safe

3. Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid

Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid

The Whirlpool broiler pan is a two-piece set made of stainless steel and a porcelain finish.

Its broiler pan has a sleek finish and is suitable for grilling, while the tray is for collecting excess oils. Its stainless steel and porcelain build makes the pan heat evenly and quickly.

The pan has undergone different tests to ensure that it works great. It also has an anti-stick feature. You can wash the pan by hand, and it is also dishwasher safe.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
The pan has a clean and modern lookIt cannot withstand high heat
It is made out of durable materialsIt’s not easy to scrub it clean
The pan is easy to clean and maintain
Ensures quick and healthy cooking

4. G&S Metal Products OvenStuff  Nonstick Broiler Pan

G&S Metal Products OvenStuff  Nonstick Broiler Pan

Measuring nine by 10.5 by 1.9 inches, the G&S broiler pan is one of the best pans for oven use.

It’s made from heavy-duty carbon steel and comes in a three-piece set.

The pan’s size makes it possible for you to cook large meals and its different parts enable you to broil, bake and roast.

Its DuraGlide nonstick coating ensures you don’t need cooking sprays or paper liners. The pan goes for a low price, making them one of the cheapest pans on the list.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
The pan is big enough for preparing large mealsThe pan is not safe for dishwashing
It comes with an anti-stick coatingThe nonstick coating peels off with time
It is affordable
It comes with a drip tray for excess oils
The pan is excellent for oven use

5. General Electric WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan for GE Range / Stove / Ovens

General Electric WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan for GE Range / Stove / Ovens

The General Electric broiler pan measures 16.75 by 12.62 by 1.37, making it one of the largest pans on the list.

It is a two-piece set made of industrial-grade steel coated with nonstick ceramic, distributing heat quickly and evenly.

Its large build makes it perfect for large meals. It’s also safe to wash it in a dishwasher.

Despite being designed for General Electric ovens, the broiler pan also works well with other medium-sized ovens.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
Can withstand high temperaturesThe pan has sharp edges
It comes with a drip tray to collect excess oilThe nonstick coating comes off after several washes
The pan is made for large meals
The pan is dishwasher safe
It comes coated with nonstick material

6. Norpro Two Piece Broil / Roast Pan set

Norpro Two Piece Broil / Roast Pan set

The pan is made of stainless steel, and its perforated top makes it great for cooking meat.

It measures nine by 12 by 1.5 inches and is best suited for smaller meals. The pan’s build makes it durable and can withstand heavy kitchen use.

The pan is also lightweight, portable, and easy to clean.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
The pan is lightweight and durableThe pan is not suitable for large meals
Its perforated top drains excess oils from meatIt does not have a nonstick coating
You can use the pan in different cooking modes
The pan does not rust

7. DCS Deals Disposable Broiler Pan – 15-Piece Sheet Pans

DCS Deals Disposable Broiler Pan – 15-Piece Sheet Pans

Some broiler pans come designed for a specific purpose, and the DCS disposable pan fits this description.

This 15-piece pan set is made of a strong aluminum foil sheet and is suited for grilling different types of meat.

Its lightweight makes the pan portable and distributes heat evenly too. Despite its disposable nature, you can use it in the oven and can recycle it after use.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
The set comprises 15 disposable broiler pansThe pan is not nonstick
The pan has a ribbed bottomThe pan cannot cook large meals
It is oven and freezer safe
You can recycle the pan
Suitable for traveling

8. Wilton Non-stick Broiler Baking Pan Set

Wilton Non-stick Broiler Baking Pan Set

The Wilton broiler pan measures 7.98 by 13.25 by 2.23 inches and is an excellent choice for first-time cooks.

It’s made from steel and coated with a nonstick material that makes it easy to clean. The pan has a drip tray that drains excess fat from the meat.

It also comes with handles adding to its functionality and is an excellent fit for most ovens. The pan is durable, comes dishwasher safe, and has a 5-year limited warranty.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
The pan has handles, making it easy to useIt should be washed by hand for better longevity
The pan comes coated with nonstick coatingThe pan might rust after extensive use
It is dishwasher safe
It comes with a drip pan
It has a 5-year limited warranty

9. G&S OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan and Toaster

G&S OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan and Toaster

The G&S broiler pan measures 6.5 by 1.75 by 8.5 inches, making it the smallest pan in the list.

It is made of carbon steel and has a DuraGlide Plus nonstick coating. The pan can also be used in a toaster oven.

The pan is versatile; it can broil, bake, and roast and has a drip pan to collect any excess fat.

Its heavy-duty construction makes the pan heavy but ensures equal heat distribution throughout the pan.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
The pan is best used in toaster ovensThe pan is not dishwasher safe
Its small design makes it suitable for smaller meals
It has nonstick properties
The pan is affordable

10. Nordic Ware 2-Piece Compact Broiler Pan

Nordic Ware 2-Piece Compact Broiler Pan

The Nordic Ware broiler pan is a compact pan measuring ten by seven by 0.63 inches.

The pan is also lightweight, weighing 0.6 pounds, making it portable for camping. It is coated with a nonstick finish, and its size makes it excellent for small storage spaces.

It’s also versatile as it can be used in regular and toaster ovens. It’s durable and can withstand high temperatures since it’s made of Aluminum. Its drip and grill make it easy to wash.

What We LikedWhat We Did Not Like
The pan has nonstick propertiesIt cannot cook large meals
The pan is lightweight and compact, suitable for campingThe pan is not dishwasher safe
It can be used indoors and outdoors
It comes at an affordable price
It can withstand high heat

What to Look for When Buying a Broiler Pan?

There are different types of broiler pans in the market. Without the correct information about them, you might buy one that will not serve your expectations right.

Best Broiler Pan

Here are the factors you should consider when shopping for the best broiler pan:

Material of the Pan

The materials used to make the broiler pan are essential in determining whether the pan will be helpful over a long period.

The most common materials used to manufacture broiler pans include stainless steel, aluminum, carbon steel, and porcelain.

Coating of the Pan

A broiler pan with a nonstick coating prevents cooked meals from sticking to the pan. Look out for pans that do not lose their coating easily, whether through accidental falls or scratches.

Size of the Pan

The size of the pan is essential when shopping for a broiler pan. A small pan will be easy to use around the kitchen, but it may not be useful when cooking large meals. These pans are available in different sizes. Look out for one that would fit your oven.

Durability

Broiler pan materials have varying durability levels. Stainless steel pans may be durable, but some food may stick to them.

Porcelain may release food better than stainless steel, but it may be challenging to remove baked-on grease.

The nonstick variety is easy to clean but requires a lot of care. Your choice depends on its convenience based on these factors.

Construction of the Pan

A broiler reflects the heat to the top of the food and can withstand temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

A well-constructed pan should be able to handle such temperatures without having its nonstick element coming off.

Ease of Cleaning

Many broiler pans are suitable for dishwashing. However, look out for an option that allows dishwashing and handwashing.

The nonstick option tops the list of broiler pans that are easy to clean.

Versatility

Broiler pans are typically limited to meat, but some options can cook other types of foods.

Retaining a broiler pan that can cook different foods is best for your budget and reduces the number of utensils in your kitchen.

Having a broiler pan for every type of food to be cooked in an oven will undoubtedly clutter your kitchen.

The Best pick Overall

Every broiler pan in this list is a great pick. However, the G&S Three-piece broiler tops the list due to its build and versatility.

The 3-piece set makes it suitable for broiling, baking, and grilling. You can also prepare different foods on the pan, which in nonstick properties makes cleaning easy after use.

Its construction makes the pan durable and can withstand heavy use. These features make the G&S broiler pan the most functional pan on the list.

The Final Verdict

The broiler pan is a valuable piece of cookware every kitchen should have. The pan’s build ensures heat retention, shortening the time it takes to cook the food. It also ensures that the heat is equally distributed, making the food cook evenly and healthily.

These pans are easy to clean, while others come dishwasher-safe. If they are properly taken care of, these pans will last a long time.

Did you like our list of the best broiler pans? Take the next step and get one for yourself today. We wish you all the best as you cook with your broiler pan.

That’s it.

Thanks for reading!